Got a new radiator and compared it to the old one and they were identical besides.... that the new one is at least twice as thick. So I guess when it warms up tomorrow ill have to take the the that is on there right now off and see how it compares with the new one I just got.
I'm wondering if maybe the other one I bought was too thick as well. I hadn't thought of that before.
I don't know, but the thickness should not matter, as the expensive radiators are thicker for better cooling.
The fender style after yours(whatever year got the factory speedometer, 2011??) had hood clearance for a thicker radiator, and the 2015+ do too.
It's been too long since I've looked at or worked on the early models like yours, but I'm almost certain there is room for it to be thicker on those too.
There is also enough clearance alone between the radiator and an aftermarket metal radiator grill/guard to be filled in with more radiator core, so I would happy getting a thicker radiator for a replacement.
It's just the length and width that need to be right.
Can you take pictures for comparison?